Force response menu bug?

[Rafiki]

Hi, during testing the "Conversations Evaluate Conditions One Extra Level Ahead", I guess I found a bug.

bug011.png (34.19 KiB) Viewed 674 times

The nodes are like this,I do it as the tutorial, between the "Hi" and "Hello" is a node with the "Continue()"sequence, and there is a simple boolen condition check on both "Hello" and "How are you".

bug02.png (71.72 KiB) Viewed 674 times

But when the "Hello" and "How are you"'s actor are both "Player",the conversation will be forced to display as a response menu .

bug012.png (71.61 KiB) Viewed 674 times

bug03.png (73.21 KiB) Viewed 674 times

bug013.png (1013.62 KiB) Viewed 674 times

If I edit one of the "Hello" and "How are you" nodes' actor to another actor , the conversation will just display normally as before.

bug15.png (73.43 KiB) Viewed 674 times

bug014.png (1006.83 KiB) Viewed 674 times

Didn't know if this is a bug , thanks!
(btw the version is 2.2.46.1)

[Tony Li]

Hi,

I can't reproduce this bug. Is the correct dialogue database asset assigned to your Dialogue Manager GameObject's Initial Database field?

If you temporarily set the Dialogue Manager's Other Settings > Debug Level to Info and play the scene, it will log details to the Console window. Look for lines like:

Code: Select all

Dialogue System: Add link [#:3] 'Hello!'

or:

Code: Select all

Dialogue System: Block on False Link [#:4] 'How are you?' (Variable["BattleWin"] == false)

You should see one "Add link" (for the entry whose Conditions are true) and one "Block on False Link" (for the entry whose Conditions are false).


Can you back up your project and update to DS version 2.2.47?

[Rafiki]

Hi,

I can't reproduce this bug. Is the correct dialogue database asset assigned to your Dialogue Manager GameObject's Initial Database field?

If you temporarily set the Dialogue Manager's Other Settings > Debug Level to Info and play the scene, it will log details to the Console window. Look for lines like:

Code: Select all

Dialogue System: Add link [#:3] 'Hello!'

or:

Code: Select all

Dialogue System: Block on False Link [#:4] 'How are you?' (Variable["BattleWin"] == false)

You should see one "Add link" (for the entry whose Conditions are true) and one "Block on False Link" (for the entry whose Conditions are false).


Can you back up your project and update to DS version 2.2.47?

Thanks for reply!
Here are the different console with the two situation.
This is the bug one.

bugconsole.png (107.21 KiB) Viewed 655 times

This is the normal one.

bugconsole01.png (108.5 KiB) Viewed 655 times

The bug one seems ask for the varibles twice, but I didn't turn on the "Reevaluate Links After Subtitle" option, and this should not affect the dialog turn to response menu.

I checked the initial Database , it is the only database I use in this project ,dose this matters?

database.png (13.28 KiB) Viewed 655 times

For the DS version , I checked the package manager and couldn't find any update , is it the unity version problem? I'm using 2022.3.26f1.

update.png (59.18 KiB) Viewed 655 times

For testing, I disable all the script on the Dialogue Manager, but this still happened.

Then I create a new unity project try to reproduce this bug , and I did it .
The most important setting is "include invalid entries" ,tick this option and this bug happens again.

bugnewproject.png (533.75 KiB) Viewed 655 times

I guess It's just a bug. Is this setting should only affect when using response menu?
And sure after I changed the actor , this bug disapear again.

bugnewproject01.png (455.96 KiB) Viewed 655 times

Got to sleep now 5am here
I will reply tomorrow, sorry to bother you Tony
Hope you could find out the answer!

[Tony Li]

Hi,

I don't think it's a bug. When you tick "Include Invalid Entries", it includes entries whose Conditions are false.

When the available links go to 2 or more Player entries (blue) and no NPC entries (gray), the Dialogue System will always show a response menu.

Would you please check the Package Manager window again? You should have access to version 2.2.47:

ds2247.png (136.85 KiB) Viewed 637 times

[Rafiki]

Hi,

I don't think it's a bug. When you tick "Include Invalid Entries", it includes entries whose Conditions are false.

When the available links go to 2 or more Player entries (blue) and no NPC entries (gray), the Dialogue System will always show a response menu.

Would you please check the Package Manager window again? You should have access to version 2.2.47:


ds2247.png

Sorry, still can't see the latest version.

update.png (99.36 KiB) Viewed 609 times

So this is a feature not a bug ?

But in this setting ,usually the player will talk as normal as Npc , I agree if there is no condition those dailog could turn to a response menu .

But if there are conditions in the two nodes , maybe it should act as a normal dialog instead of turning to a response menu?
Or do I have a way to make it act like this without disable the "Include Invalid Entries" setting?

Thanks !

[Rafiki]

third.png (440.27 KiB) Viewed 606 times

Even if I add a third node with a condition , it will still act like that.

Seems like if there are 2 player nodes, the conversation will force to be a response menu. That is annoying

[Tony Li]

No, in your screenshot above, if the Conditions for "haha" are false, then the list of possible entries will only be "hello" and "how are you?". Since these are both blue Player nodes, it will show a response menu.

If you UNtick "Include Invalid Entries", then the list will only include "hello" OR "how are you?" since it will not include entries whose Conditions are false.

[Rafiki]

No, in your screenshot above, if the Conditions for "haha" are false, then the list of possible entries will only be "hello" and "how are you?". Since these are both blue Player nodes, it will show a response menu.

If you UNtick "Include Invalid Entries", then the list will only include "hello" OR "how are you?" since it will not include entries whose Conditions are false.

So how can I make it act like normal dialog when there are two player nodes with conditions without untick "Include Invalid Entries"? Or I just can't?

[Tony Li]

Why do you want to include invalid entries if you only want to show one?

Anyway, the way to do it is to add the "[auto]" (auto-play) markup tag to the text of the blue nodes, such as "[auto]hello".

[Rafiki]

Why do you want to include invalid entries if you only want to show one?

Anyway, the way to do it is to add the "[auto]" (auto-play) markup tag to the text of the blue nodes, such as "[auto]hello".

Oh , it works! Thank you Tony!

For the reason , because I need this feature when the actual reponse menu shows but I don't need it in the normal dialog.